The four arrangements
| Cash purchase | Loan | Lease | PPA | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who owns the system | You | You | Solar company | Solar company |
| Up-front cost | Full price | Little or none | Little or none | Little or none |
| What you pay | Nothing further | Fixed loan payment | Fixed monthly rent | Price per kWh produced |
| Maintenance | You | You | Company | Company |
| Typical term | n/a | 10 to 25 years | 20 to 25 years | 20 to 25 years |
Who gets which incentive
| Incentive | If you own | If the company owns |
|---|---|---|
| Federal tax credit | None for installs after 2025 | Company may claim Section 48E, within deadlines |
| State income tax credit | You | Usually nobody, or the company |
| State or utility rebate | You (often via the installer) | Company, in most programs |
| SRECs and production payments | You | Company |
| Sales tax exemption | Reflected in your price | Reflected in the company's cost |
| Property tax exemption | You | Varies by state |
| Net metering credits | You | You, on your utility bill |
| Battery program payments | You | Depends on the contract |
The pattern is consistent: bill credits go to the customer in every case, and everything else follows ownership.
Why the comparison shifted
For installations after 31 December 2025, a homeowner who buys gets no federal credit. A company that owns the system can still claim the business credit if the project meets the construction and in-service deadlines, the last of which for solar is 31 December 2027. Batteries owned by a company remain eligible for longer.
A company's cost for a leased system is therefore lower than your cost for the same system, by an amount that depends on how much of the credit it captures and keeps. Competition decides how much is passed on. Meanwhile any state credit, SREC income or production payment is lost to you under a lease. In a state with strong owner incentives, that loss can be larger than the federal benefit the company shares. In a state with none, the lease may well be cheaper.
No general answer exists. It has to be worked out per state and per quote.
How to compare
Put each offer on the same basis: total net cost over 25 years, per kilowatt-hour produced.
Buying. Take the price after state incentives. Add loan interest if financing. Add an allowance for one inverter replacement. Subtract expected SREC or production income. Divide by 25 years of expected output.
Lease. Add up all 25 years of payments, applying the escalator. Divide by the production the contract guarantees, if it guarantees any.
PPA. Take the year-one price per kWh and apply the escalator to get the price in each year. Compare each year's price with a realistic projection of the utility rate, and remember that under net billing your exports are worth less than what you pay the PPA company for them.
That last point matters. With a PPA you pay for every kilowatt-hour the system generates. If a third of it is exported and credited at a low export rate, you may be buying power at 18¢ and being credited 6¢ for it.
The escalator
Most leases and PPAs raise the price each year, commonly by 2% to 3.5%. At 2.9% a year the price in year 25 is double the price in year one. The contract is a good deal only if utility rates rise at least as fast, every year, for a quarter of a century. Ask for a quote with no escalator, which most companies will provide at a higher starting price, and compare the two totals.
What the contract should tell you
- the year-by-year payment schedule in dollars;
- a production guarantee and what the company pays if output falls short;
- who owns SRECs, rebates and battery program payments;
- buyout prices at set points during the term;
- transfer terms when the house is sold, including any fee and credit requirement for the buyer;
- what happens at the end of the term and who pays for removal;
- whether a lien or UCC fixture filing is recorded against the property.
When each tends to make sense
Buying suits a household that has the cash or can borrow at a reasonable rate, lives in a state with incentives for owners, and expects to stay in the home for most of the payback period.
A lease or PPA suits a household without access to affordable credit, in a state where third-party ownership is permitted and owner incentives are thin, with a contract whose price stays below the utility rate throughout.
Neither may be right where power is cheap and exports earn little. A quote that shows savings only by assuming high utility inflation is a sign of this.
Is leasing solar better than buying now that the federal credit ended?
Sometimes. The leasing company can still claim a federal business credit for a limited time and may pass part of it on. But owners keep state credits, SRECs and production payments. Which effect is larger depends on your state and the specific contract.
What is the difference between a lease and a PPA?
A lease charges a fixed monthly amount regardless of output. A PPA charges for each kilowatt-hour the system produces. A PPA carries less risk if the system underperforms, and some states allow leases but restrict PPAs.
Can I buy out a solar lease?
Most contracts set buyout prices at specified dates, often from year five or six. The price is in the contract or a schedule attached to it.
Does a solar loan still make sense without the tax credit?
It can, if the monthly payment is lower than the savings or close to it. Be wary of loans with a payment that steps up unless you pay down the balance early. That structure assumed a tax credit refund that no longer arrives.
Who repairs a leased system?
The company that owns it. Under a purchase, repairs outside the installer's workmanship warranty and the manufacturer's equipment warranty are your cost.
Related
- Going solar after the federal tax credit endedWhat the end of the 30% credit changes for price, payback and how solar is sold.
- How to check the incentive claims in a solar quoteA checklist for the incentive and savings assumptions behind a proposal.
- Buying or selling a home with solar: what happens to the incentivesWhich benefits pass to the buyer, which need paperwork, and how leases are handled.