The four mechanisms
| Mechanism | What it reduces | Worth of "$1,000" | When you get it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rebate | The price you pay | $1,000 | At purchase or soon after |
| Refundable tax credit | Your tax bill, with any excess paid to you | $1,000 | When your return is processed |
| Nonrefundable tax credit | Your tax bill, down to zero | Up to $1,000, limited by tax owed | When you file, possibly over several years |
| Tax deduction | Your taxable income | $1,000 × your tax rate | When you file |
| Tax exemption | A tax that would otherwise be charged | The tax avoided | Automatically, or after an application |
Rebates
A rebate is money off. It is the simplest incentive and the most certain once you have it, because it does not depend on your tax position. Its weakness is supply: rebates are paid from budgets, and budgets run out. A rebate that was open when you were quoted may be closed when you apply. See rebates by state.
Tax credits
A credit is subtracted from the tax you owe. If you owe your state $3,200 and have a $1,000 credit, you pay $2,200.
Whether a credit is refundable matters a great deal to households with modest tax bills. Suppose a retired couple owes $400 in state income tax and qualifies for a $1,000 solar credit.
- If the credit is refundable, their tax falls to zero and the state pays them $600.
- If it is nonrefundable with carryforward, they use $400 this year and the remaining $600 against later years, if they owe enough tax in those years before the carryforward period ends.
- If it is nonrefundable with no carryforward, they receive $400 and the rest is gone.
Most state solar credits are nonrefundable with a carryforward of several years.
Credits also come with caps. A credit described as "25% of system cost, up to $1,000" is in practice a $1,000 credit for nearly everyone, since 25% of a typical system exceeds the cap many times over.
Deductions
A deduction is subtracted from your income before tax is calculated. Its value is the deduction multiplied by your marginal rate. At a 5% state rate:
- a $1,000 credit saves $1,000;
- a $1,000 deduction saves $50.
Where a state lets you deduct the cost of a solar system, the saving is real but small. A $20,000 system deducted over four years at a 5.8% rate saves $1,160 in total. That is a different order of magnitude from a 25% credit, even though both may be listed under "tax incentives".
Exemptions
An exemption removes a tax that would have applied. A sales tax exemption means no state sales tax on the equipment. A property tax exemption means the system does not raise your assessed value. Neither sends you money. They prevent a cost, and for that reason they are often left out of quotes and comparisons, though over twenty years a property tax exemption can be worth several thousand dollars. See sales tax and property tax exemptions by state.
Comparing offers on the same footing
To compare incentives of different kinds, convert each to dollars you will actually receive and note when:
- Rebates: the amount, if the program is open and funds are reserved for you.
- Credits: the lesser of the calculated credit and the cap, then the lesser of that and the tax you expect to owe over the carryforward period.
- Deductions: the deduction times your marginal state rate.
- Exemptions: the tax rate times the value exempted, each year for property tax.
A dollar received next April, or over the next five Aprils, is worth somewhat less than a dollar off the invoice today. If you are borrowing to pay for the system, the difference is the interest you pay while waiting.
Which is better, a tax credit or a rebate?
For the same dollar figure, a rebate, because you receive all of it regardless of how much tax you owe and you receive it sooner. A refundable credit is close to equivalent. A nonrefundable credit is worth the same only if you owe enough tax to use it.
What does nonrefundable mean?
The credit can reduce your tax to zero but cannot generate a payment beyond that. Any unused amount is lost unless the law allows you to carry it forward to future years.
Is a tax deduction the same as a tax credit?
No. A credit reduces your tax directly. A deduction reduces the income on which tax is calculated, so it is worth only the deduction multiplied by your tax rate.
Do I need to itemize to claim a state solar credit?
Generally not. State solar credits are claimed on their own form or schedule attached to the state return and do not depend on itemizing.